Recipe Box Empty

Make These Mystical, Magical Cookies Inspired by Benson Boone and Crumbl

A dreamy cookie recipe for when the starry collaboration vanishes June 28.

Benson Boone’s Moonbeam Ice Cream Cookie collaboration with Crumbl is here — and it’s as much a hit as the “Mystical Magical” earworm that inspired it.

A chocolate base stacked with cookies-and-cream crumbles, fruity marshmallow frosting, and a sweet, starry drizzle, the chilled creation has #FoodTok singing its praises.

That’s the amazing news. The less-than-amazing news? This sugar-fueled daydream vanishes after June 28. Total disappearing act.

But don’t cry over spilled crumbs — we’ve whipped up a few mystical, magical, totally make-at-home recipes inspired by the cookie’s vibe. Just choose your cookie, frosting, then drizzle to keep that moonbeam energy flowing long after the collab disappears into the cosmos.

For the Cookie

For the Frosting

For the Drizzle

Share Your Favorite Cookie Recipes

We’d love to see your own creations. So, be sure to leave a review with pics of your recipes.

Loved this take on the Benson Boone x Crumbl cookie collaboration? See what else is trending on Chopped.

Top image courtesy of Crumbl.



Chopped is powered by people alongside Cookie, our AI sous-chef. Every cook and kitchen is unique, so be sure to check seasoning, temperature, and cook time as you go. Consult packaging for dietary information and always follow food safety guidelines.



0.0
0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Excellent0%
Very good0%
Average0%
Poor0%
Terrible0%


There are no reviews yet. Be the first to write one.